Thoughts on production, alienation, and ideology

Category: Class (Page 2 of 24)

Anti-Capitalist Capitalism and the Church of HR

The world has developed a few striking new features since 2020 – since the pandemic and the protests in response to the police murder of George Floyd. Among those features, here’s one that stands out to me: the rise of explicitly anti-capitalist branding within the capitalist system.

That is to say, people and companies use anti-capitalist messages, logos, and slogans in order to sell things to people or push companies and their workers toward efficiency and profit. So, we’re not just talking about Che Guevara t-shirts here.

It goes deeper than that.

A few years ago, I wrote about one facet of this that we might call ‘Woke HR.’ But let’s look into this a bit further.

Continue reading

Identitarians Can’t Explain Harris

The tide turned hard against the Biden campaign about a week after the debate, around the July 4 holiday.  When it happened, my thoughts turned to an old debate at the heart of this blog.

Across many posts, I ask the question: what force drives society at its most fundamental level? At the ground, do we find a system of class relations and class conflict? Or do we find identities such as race and gender? Marxists argue for the former, while identitarians argue for the latter.

Joe Biden’s decision to step down in favor of Kamala Harris suggests, strongly, that it can’t be the latter. At the very least, it suggests the left-leaning version of identitarianism doesn’t work. And the far right version never made much sense, anyway.

Continue reading

The Conners and the Working Class

A few years ago, I had some thoughts on the working class politics of the returned TV show Roseanne. The gist of it is that I thought the show played Roseanne’s title character in a plausible way. Yes, they turned her from a fairly left-leaning working class woman into a Trump supporter. But they did so in a way that rang true to her character and the character’s likely development.

Fast forward a few years. Now I’ve had a chance to watch most of seasons 2 and 3 of The Conners, the updated version of the show after Roseanne herself got booted.

What do I see here?

Continue reading

Jacobin Study, Part 3: Left Populism

In two previous posts (Part 1 and Part 2), I detailed studies sponsored by Jacobin magazine on working-class politics and the left. Among other things, the studies concluded that voters prefer a ‘progressive populist’ (and later, ‘left populism’) message to a ‘woke progressive’ message. Readers can review the links above.

In my discussion of those studies, I pointed out that while the electorate – especially working-class voters – prefer left populism, they’re not yet on board with many left policy ideas. We have an electorate open to us. But we haven’t yet reached it. And so our task should involve building a majority. Not simply assuming our majority is already out there.

Continue reading

Power and Powerlessness

I recently read a classic in political sociology – Power and Powerlessness by John Gaventa. It’s an insightful attempt to apply the Steven Lukes analysis of power – laid out in a book by that title – to the situation of coal miners in central Appalachia.

Gaventa seeks to explain why oppressed Appalachian miners refuse to rise up in revolt against their oppressors. While he argues for the intuitive view that the power of the mining companies prevents them from doing so, he gets there via an interesting and compelling route. Ultimately, he argues that the power of the mining companies consists, in part, in their ability to change the desires and aims of miners. Rebellion comes only when we alter those underlying power relationships.

I think we can learn a lot from Gaventa about power and powerlessness.

Continue reading

« Older posts Newer posts »