Thoughts on production, alienation, and ideology

Category: Activism (Page 2 of 26)

These are posts on activism from the blog Base and Superstructure. This takes many forms. The focus here is on political activism, above all on activist organizing and base-building. One concern is how to build effective movements. There’s also a need to create solidarity with fellow members and build coalitions with other groups. The main aim of good movements is to work together to advance material interests. This section also includes critiques of electoral work, and discussion of how and when to use elections to advance activist goals. Navigating the balance between grassroots work and electoral work is difficult for everyone.

A Word On The Israel-Gaza War

Destroyed buildings in Gaza. Buildings destroyed by Israel.

A few readers have noted that I haven’t posted on the Israel-Gaza War. The war has raged since last October, at times overtaking the news and even U.S. political debate.

That’s true enough. I haven’t written anything new on Israel and Gaza in the last few months. Here’s a brief word about why.

First, the things I said a few years ago about the Israel Palestine Conflict, sadly, still apply pretty well. I wrote a post in 2019 introducing readers to the conflict. I also expanded the post into a full chapter in my second book, Left Foreign Policy. In those outlets, I laid out the conflict as one primarily about resources, which then drives the moves Israel makes as the hegemonic power in the region.

Predictably, much of the mainstream press presents the conflict as one about religion or (Israeli) national security. Almost all sources fail to identify the ongoing Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip as the major cause of the current fighting. This all leads the press astray.

Second, I’ve found a few sources worth following closely. Both for the day to day details of the conflict and broader analysis. Early in the Israel Gaza War, the American Prestige podcast established itself as an great source for news, interviews, and commentary. +972 magazine also stands out as a solid source that moves beyond the pro-Israel biases that pervade the U.S. press.

Finally, I’ll admit that I struggle to find useful things to say about the Israel Gaza War. Not that there aren’t things to say, but rather that most of the things worth saying won’t help move us toward a better outcome.

I’ve moved past that phase of life where I think personal displays of awareness on social media do anything positive. Rather, I think people – myself and readers all included – should join orgs like DSA that are trying to build a better U.S. left. DSA, better than any other org, works an internationalist perspective on the Israel Gaza War into a deeper vision of what the left can become. Shouting into the void on Twitter – or even joining single-issue orgs – can’t do anything like that.

Image Source

Am I An Abolitionist, Too?

I’ve written specifically about prison abolition on this blog. But I haven’t written about modern abolitionism as a movement. Nor have I specified whether I’m an abolitionist. In that previous post, I discussed how disagreements over the concept of ‘prison’ produces misunderstandings. It clouds political debates in ways we can, and should, get past.

Of course, I wrote that first post 4 years ago. These debates took quite a turn in the summer of 2020. A more comprehensive abolitionist movement emerged into the stage of mainstream politics.

How does abolitionism, in its modern form, relate to prison abolition?

Continue reading

The Frustrations of College Town Activism

I turned 40 last year, and I’ve reached a moment where I’m looking back at my activist history and thinking about my activist future. Among other things, that involves looking back at the frustrations of college town activism. And since I’ve spent the last 6 years as a member of Democratic Socialists of America, that means the frustrations of organizing with a socialist group in a progressive college town.

The landscape in our progressive college town features lots and lots of community activist groups. What frustrations could there be here? In a town full of progressive activist groups with goals broadly compatible to those of DSA, especially in the short term?

Oh, a few…

Continue reading

Two Deeper Problems for the Implicit Association Test

Anyone following the replication crisis (and other debates) in the social sciences knows about one key problem with the implicit association test. In short, it’s not clear whether the test predicts anything. That is to say, ‘implicit bias,’ as measured by the IAT, might not predict prejudice or discriminatory behavior.

That’s a problem for the IAT for the obvious reason that its creators intend it as a major tool in the fight against racism, sexism, and other forms of oppression.

But I want to suggest that the IAT has even deeper problems. At least two of them. Even if the IAT does predict behavior, it still doesn’t explain a lot about why racism and sexism and happen. Nor does it tells us how to fight them.

Continue reading

Rethinking the New Left?

As readers may have noticed, I have a habit of writing about the New Left in a derogatory way.

I complain about its bad habits. I lament its navel gazing, its development of alienating leftist subculture, and its embrace of open-ended, structureless meetings. And more than anything, I think it’s unfortunate the New Left still influences new activist groups.

So, it’s fair to say I was overdue for a correction from more sober historians.

Never fear, dear reader. That day has arrived!

Continue reading

« Older posts Newer posts »